Verified from 12 cited sources and the canonical match record.
Pre-match Elo1586 → 1593(+8)
Newton Heath 68%32% Gainsborough Trinity
Newton Heath went in as the favourite by rating, 1586 to Gainsborough Trinity’s 1514.
MUFCInfo match lineups
Datareference
attendance:supporting, result, starting-lineup, united-scorers
attendance:supporting, result, starting-lineup, united-scorers
engsoccerdata
Datadataset
attendance:supporting, result, starting-lineup, united-scorers