Saturday 6 February 1904

Drawn

Notts County
3–3
Man Utd

5′
Downie
18′
Schofield
63′
Arkesden
11′
Ross
47′
Humphreys
61′
Humphreys
0′HTFT
  1. 5' Alex Downie
  2. 11' William Ross
  3. 18' Alf Schofield
  4. 47' Percy Humphreys
  5. 61' Percy Humphreys
  6. 63' Tommy Arkesden

Starting XI

11Robertson10Arkesden9Grassam8Morrison7Schofield
6Robertson5Griffiths4Downie
3Hayes2Bonthron
1Sutcliffe

2-3-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.