Saturday 31 October 1908

Lost

Sunderland
6–1
Man Utd

17′
Turnbull
2′
Bridgett
15′
Brown
38′
Bridgett
56′
Holley
80′
Brown
89′
Holley
0′HTFT
  1. 2' Arthur Bridgett
  2. 15' Arthur Brown
  3. 17' Sandy Turnbull
  4. 38' Arthur Bridgett
  5. 56' George Holley
  6. 80' Arthur Brown
  7. 89' George Holley

Starting XI

11Wall10Turnbull9Turnbull8Halse7Meredith
6Thomson5Downie4Duckworth
3Burgess2Stacey
1Moger

2-3-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.