Saturday 27 January 1912

Lost

Sunderland
5–0
Man Utd

43′
Holley
48′
Holley
52′
Holley
73′
Buchan
86′
Holley
0′HTFT
  1. 43' George Holley
  2. 48' George Holley
  3. 52' George Holley
  4. 73' Charlie Buchan
  5. 86' George Holley

Goalscorer data for this match may be incomplete.

Starting XI

11Wall10Turnbull9Whalley8Hamill7Meredith
6Bell5Roberts4Duckworth
3Stacey2Holden
1Edmonds

2-3-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 16 cited sources and the canonical match record.