Saturday 22 December 1923

Won

Man Utd
5–0
Port Vale

5′
Bain
24′
Bain
61′
Lochhead
67′
Bain
83′
Spence (P)
0′HTFT
  1. 5' David Bain
  2. 24' David Bain
  3. 61' Arthur Lochhead
  4. 67' David Bain
  5. 83' Joe Spence (penalty)

Starting XI

11McPherson10Lochhead9Bain×38Mann7Spence
6Hilditch5Grimwood4Bennion
3Moore2Radford
1Steward

2-3-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 16 cited sources and the canonical match record.