Saturday 28 December 1935

Won

Man Utd
3–2
Plymouth

22′
Mutch
65′
Manley
78′
Mutch
51′
McNeil
71′
Sloan
0′HTFT
  1. 22' George Mutch
  2. 51' Johnny McNeil
  3. 65' Tom Manley
  4. 71' Frank Sloan
  5. 78' George Mutch

Starting XI

11Manley10Rowley9Mutch×28Gardner7Cape
6McKay4Brown
3Porter5Vose2Griffiths
1Hall

3-2-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.