Saturday 1 February 1958

Won

Arsenal
4–5
Man Utd

58′
Herd
60′
Bloomfield
61′
Bloomfield
77′
Tapscott
0′HTFT
  1. 58' David Herd
  2. 60' Jimmy Bloomfield
  3. 61' Jimmy Bloomfield
  4. 77' Derek Tapscott

Starting XI

10Viollet9Taylor×2
11Scanlon8Charlton4Colman7Morgans
3Byrne6Edwards5Jones2Foulkes
1Gregg

4-4-2 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.