Saturday 18 October 1958

Lost

Everton
32
Man Utd

19
Thomas
37
Thomas
55
Harris
0′HTFT
  1. 19' Eddie Thomas
  2. 37' Eddie Thomas
  3. 55' Jimmy Harris

Starting XI

4-4-2 approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.