Tuesday 7 October 1986

Won

Port Vale
2–5
Man Utd

34′
Stapleton
71′
Barnes
75′
Moses
77′
Davenport (P)
89′
Moses
52′
Jones (P)
80′
Sivebaek (OG)
0′HTFT
  1. 34' Frank Stapleton
  2. 52' Andy Jones (penalty)
  3. 71' Peter Barnes
  4. 75' Remi Moses
  5. 77' Peter Davenport (penalty)
  6. 80' Johnny Sivebaek (own goal)
  7. 89' Remi Moses

Starting XI

10Davenport9Stapleton
11Barnes8Strachan4Moses×27Robson
3Albiston6Moran5McGrath2Sivebæk
1Turner

4-4-2 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 15 cited sources and the canonical match record.