Saturday 12 December 1908

Won

Man Utd
4–2
Leicester

23′
Wall
37′
Wall
60′
Picken
69′
Wall
29′
Hubbard
86′
Donnelly
0′HTFT
  1. 23' George Wall
  2. 29' Shirley Hubbard
  3. 37' George Wall
  4. 60' Jack Picken
  5. 69' George Wall
  6. 86' Jimmy Donnelly

Starting XI

11Hardman10Wall×39Picken8Halse7Meredith
6Downie5Curry4Duckworth
3Hayes2Linkson
1Moger

2-3-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.